Menu of Mi Cerrito Mexican Restaurant Bucyrus in Bucyrus, Ohio, USA

Menu Overview

Mi Cerrito Mexican Restaurant Bucyrus emerges as a vibrant culinary beacon in the heart of Bucyrus, OH, offering a refined take on traditional Mexican fare. Nestled at 144 Washington Square, this establishment quickly gained attention post-opening for blending an inviting atmosphere with a menu that honors authenticity while embracing innovation.

The hallmark of Mi Cerrito’s menu is undoubtedly the Gourmet Tacos. The “Everything Tacos” feature an inspired double-decker combination utilizing blue corn tortillas, layered generously with your choice of grilled chicken, steak, or shrimp alongside chorizo, melted mozzarella and cheddar, salsa verde, and ranchero sauce. This complex flavor profile, balanced by cool lettuce and pico de gallo, speaks to the kitchen’s expertise in marrying textures and tastes. At $17.24 for three tacos, this dish anchors the menu with richness and depth.

Equally compelling are the chicken dishes, such as the Pollo Sonora. The marinated chicken breast, paired with bacon-wrapped shrimp, grilled onions, mushrooms, and topped with fresh pico de gallo and queso, offers an interplay of smoky, savory, and fresh elements that redefine expectations. The accompanying sides—Mexican rice and garden salad—complement without overshadowing. The Pollo Loco stands out with its robust cheese layering and the comforting presence of crema salad and soft flour tortillas, embodying classic Mexican warmth with a gourmet touch.

Drinks like the traditional Aguas Frescas provide a refreshing counterpoint to the bold flavors, reinforcing the authenticity of the dining experience.

From feedback woven through various patron reviews, several themes emerge that elevate Mi Cerrito. Guests consistently praise the service quality, highlighting attentive staff such as Kaylee, whose hospitality enhances the overall experience. The interior design garners acclaim as well, with modern features like driftwood chandeliers and large screens projecting sports, crafting an atmosphere that feels both polished and welcoming. This ambiance, coupled with a non-traditional music selection mixing modern Mexican genres, results in an environment that’s lively but approachable—suitable for intimate dinners, family outings, or casual gatherings alike.

Food-wise, patrons note that the kitchen balances innovation with tradition. The standout dish by one reviewer—the cheesy molcajete—arrives as a multi-component feast, with bacon-wrapped shrimp, street corn, and fresh poblano peppers enriching a savory, cheese-laden mixture that delivers both heft and flavor complexity. Freshness resonates, too, as highlighted by perfectly made flour tortillas and creamy, flavorful refried beans that defy the bland stereotype. Although a few minor critiques appear, like the suggestion to enliven the pink rice with olive oil, lime, and cilantro, these are overshadowed by consistently positive impressions of ingredient quality and execution.

Mi Cerrito's expansive menu, spanning several pages, offers ample variety without diluting focus, ensuring diners find both familiar and unique Mexican dishes executed with care. This balance of broad choice and consistent excellence encourages repeat visits and exploration. The restaurant’s ability to handle a high volume of orders efficiently—with meals served quickly and at an ideal temperature—enhances its appeal for both leisurely meals and more spontaneous culinary excursions.

In sum, Mi Cerrito Mexican Restaurant Bucyrus represents a thoughtful, modern homage to Mexican cuisine. It successfully bridges traditional flavors with contemporary presentation and hospitality. For those seeking a refined but unpretentious yet deeply satisfying Mexican meal—be it gourmet tacos, inventive chicken entrees, or vibrant sides—Mi Cerrito stands out as a worthy destination. Whether you are a local or traveling through Ohio, this restaurant promises a memorable taste of Mexico that’s as genuine as it is fresh.