Overview

Mi Cerrito Mexican Restaurant Bucyrus stands out as a fresh and vibrant addition to the local dining scene, located conveniently at 144 Washington Square in Bucyrus, Ohio. This establishment offers an inviting atmosphere that blends modern design with cultural touches. The interior is well-lit, featuring striking driftwood chandeliers and large TVs tuned to sporting events, creating a welcoming environment perfect for a variety of diners—from casual families to intimate date nights.

The culinary experience at Mi Cerrito is anchored by expertly prepared Mexican classics with a modern twist. Their fajitas, whether chicken, steak, shrimp, or inventive combinations like the Tejana Fajita, arrive sizzling and packed with tender, flavorful meats. The Chicken Pollo Loco and ChoriPollo showcase a fine balance of marinated ingredients topped generously with melted cheeses, served alongside fresh flour tortillas, Mexican rice, refried beans, and crema salad, complementing the rich main dishes without overpowering them.

One of the highlights is the care taken in the sides. Unlike the typical fillers often found at Mexican eateries, the refried beans here are freshly made, creamy, and full of character. The street corn and fresh greens bring brightness with well-considered touches like lime wedges, elevating the overall meal. Even the salsa breaks away from tradition, with a cilantro-heavy mix that surprises by avoiding the usual soapy notes some diners encounter—an indication of thoughtful kitchen craftsmanship.

Service at Mi Cerrito consistently receives praise for its attentiveness and friendliness, enhancing the dining experience. Whether it’s the efficiency of food delivery or the warm, knowledgeable staff like Kaylee, customers feel valued. The team seems to understand the importance of balancing speed with genuine care, making the meal both quick and comforting.

Mi Cerrito’s space is flexible and inviting—a modern, clean environment suitable for quiet dinners or lively gatherings. Its blend of authentic flavors and contemporary ambiance appeals to a broad audience, particularly those seeking flavors beyond the standard Mexican fare common in smaller towns. The mix of traditional dishes and innovative touches, such as their approach to molcajete plates and black garlic-infused options, suggests a menu willing to surprise and satisfy.

In sum, Mi Cerrito Mexican Restaurant Bucyrus offers more than just a meal—it invites you into a well-crafted experience combining atmosphere, attention to detail, and flavorful Mexican cuisine. It’s a promising destination for locals and visitors alike who appreciate a vibrant yet approachable setting paired with thoughtful, high-quality dishes.


Amenities & Services

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Comfort food
Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy

What Customers Say

Kellie Castle
Mar 26,2026
4/5
This is a new location I visited it the first Friday evening after grand opening. Service was good wait for table was a little long but I'm sure it was due to first week being open.
Joe Graham
Mar 26,2026
4/5
First of all, thank you Kaylee for excellent service! I was so torn beginning this review. First of all, we walked in not knowing what to expect. The interior remake is spectacular. MC have truly made it their own. It's modern and well-lit (those driftwood chandeliers!) The walls are hung with large TV's showing various sporting events. The one holdover would seem to be the speaker system, which refreshingly enough plays a mix of modern Mexican music -- not Mariachi music. We were served the standard chips and salsa. The salsa was cilantro heavy, but we really liked it. I'm one of those unfortunate people for whom cilantro tastes like soap. Either someone is a wizard in the kitchen, or they possibly used epazote? In any case, I'm a fan! I'll be dancing mostly through extraordinary high points, and a few trivial low points. The thing is, the high points were so high that the low points are only mentioned as minor points of improvement. I couldn't bring myself to deduct a star for less than fresh free tortilla chips or the standard bland pink rice. My husband ordered the steak fajitas. I ordered what I thought would be a plain old cheesy molcajete. Our meals were quickly delivered to our table, sizzling happily of course. My husband's fajitas were delicious. They were mildly seasoned, with a huge serving of tender steak. He really enjoyed them, and we brought some home. Now, the molcajete. I have eaten at good tápas restaurants. The molcajete mixture was buried under what amounted to three plates of tápas, all stunning and wonderful. Between the skewer of perfect juicy bacon-wrapped large shrimp, the half ear of street corn, the fried cheese, and the fresh poblano, both as a garnish and for added heat, we could have had delicious appetizers for two. My husband noted the flour tortillas were fresh, by the way. He was raised in south Texas. He knows his tortillas. When I finally got to the molcajete mixture, it was was juicy and full of cheese. It was loaded with meat, and very savory. It could have served two normal people. Now, who reviews the side plates? I will here. Wow. I told you about the boring rice (Folks, just add a bit of olive oil, a squirt of lime juice, and a bit of chopped cilantro right before serving. Pink rice must be abolished!) A lime wedge provided perfect tartness for the street corn and the small fresh greens. One more wedge would have been nice for the shrimp and the molcajete mixture. Minor! So. Boring old refried beans. Nope. These were freshly made and creamy. They actually had flavor. I could have eaten a plate of these. I understand there were some starting hiccups. It happens. That's why we waited. This restaurant is a really nice. It is waiting for large parties of people. It's great for an intimate date night, dressed up people, dressed down people, and families. If the kitchen isn't catering yet, they should be. Mi Cerrito is a wonderful addition to Bucyrus, and it's worth a road trip if you want different flavors than standard Mexican restaurant fare. I am looking forward to trying their carnitas, and their dishes made with black garlic intrigue me. We're going back soon!
Chelsea Gottfried
Mar 26,2026
5/5
The absolute best salsa! Waitress was super friendly and attentive, and they did an amazing job with the interior design—love the driftwood lighting and accents. So nice, especially for a small town.
Guy Campo
Mar 26,2026
5/5
Very Clean. Nice Atmosphere.Food very good. Service Excellent.
Paul “nubbs” Holmes
Mar 26,2026
5/5
Excellent service. Really great food. A 4 page menu, so there's plenty to pick from. Food came out fast and Really hot. I would definitely be going back soon
T. Dye
Mar 26,2026
5/5
Super nice inside, the food is very good ... parking in the rear of the business and across the street in the front
Sarah Steele
Mar 26,2026
5/5
So good. Great food, great service, decent prices. Love this place!
terry compton
Mar 26,2026
5/5
Good food quick and friendly. Relaxing atmosphere. Music loud enough for casual conversations without hearing other tables

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

Monday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Tuesday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Wednesday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Thursday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Friday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Saturday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sunday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Top Picks for You

More in Bucyrus, Ohio, USA

Handpicked spots for food lovers. Your next favorite meal awaits!